Compare Agent Identity and service accounts

Traditional cloud workloads typically rely on service accounts to authenticate deterministic applications, batch jobs, and backend services. Generative AI agents introduce distinct security and governance requirements because they act like digital workers rather than static workloads.

An agent can plan, reason dynamically, execute multi-step workflows, and call external tools either on its own authority or on behalf of human users. Reusing shared, long-lived service account credentials for agents increases the risk of credential exfiltration, over-permissioned workloads, and ambiguous audit trails.

Agent Identity provisions a dedicated, lifecycle-bound cryptographic identity for each agent. The following table compares standard service accounts and agent identities:

Characteristic Service accounts Agent identities (Agent Identity)
Identity model Shared workload identity that is often reused across multiple instances or microservices. Unique, cryptographically attested SPIFFE ID provisioned for each deployed agent.
Workload role Designed for deterministic backend services, background batch processing, and server-to-server APIs. Designed for autonomous agents that perform reasoning, multi-turn conversations, and external tool execution.
Credential security Relies on bearer tokens or downloadable, long-lived service account keys that can be intercepted or exfiltrated. Uses ephemeral, certificate-bound tokens protected by Context-Aware Access policies for Google Cloud APIs and OpenID Connect (OIDC) ID tokens for external services, preventing token replay outside the trusted runtime environment.
Human user delegation Frequently relies on service account impersonation, which grants broad privileges and can obscure the initiating user in audit trails. Uses explicit user-delegated authority through 3-legged OAuth (3LO) brokered by Agent Identity auth manager. Avoids impersonation and preserves the user's identity.
Tool credential mediation Applications manage API keys, client secrets, and third-party tokens directly within application code, environment variables, or secret vaults. Agent Identity auth manager stores and brokers API keys and OAuth tokens, and Agent Gateway enforces outbound access policies, keeping raw secrets and refresh tokens out of the model runtime.
Auditability and governance Audit logs record the service account as the principal, requiring manual correlation to determine which user or request initiated an action. Audit logs record the agent's unique SPIFFE identity for autonomous actions and capture dual attribution for delegated actions, logging both the agent identity and the delegating user.
Access boundaries Grants Identity and Access Management (IAM) roles to a shared service account across all workloads that attach or impersonate that account. Enforces least privilege by granting IAM roles to each specific agent identity, integrated with Principal Access Boundary (PAB) policies and Agent Registry.

What's next